Dallas Parents File Lawsuit After Failed Delivery Procedure Leads to Newborn’s Death
In a heartbreaking case unfolding in Dallas County, parents Emerald Giles-Perkins and Darryl Perkins have filed a lawsuit against Methodist Dallas Medical Center and OB-GYN Dr. Theresa Patton. The family alleges that a series of medical errors during childbirth led to the death of their newborn son, Prime, just one day after his birth in April 2024.
According to the lawsuit, Giles-Perkins experienced what had otherwise been an uncomplicated pregnancy until labor stalled after her water broke. In response, Dr. Patton reportedly attempted a vacuum-assisted delivery, attaching a suction device to the baby’s head to guide him through the birth canal. The lawsuit claims this device was used at least four times without success. Medical staff eventually performed an emergency C-section to deliver Prime; he appeared healthy at first and was welcomed by his parents. However, within 24 hours, the baby’s condition rapidly declined.
Hospital staff initially attributed Prime’s deteriorating health to a potential infection from the mother. As his condition worsened, Giles-Perkins and Perkins, desperate for answers, commissioned an independent autopsy. Results from Mesquite-based American Forensics revealed extensive brain hemorrhages. The pathologist concluded that Prime’s injuries were consistent with trauma from repeated vacuum-assisted delivery attempts, asserting the baby died due to complications from childbirth—not infection.
In interviews, the couple shared their grief—Giles-Perkins recalled holding her son for just minutes before he passed away. Darryl Perkins described his wife’s anguish the moment she was rushed to the neonatal intensive care unit, saying the sight of her agony is etched in his memory.
Their attorney, Geoff Henley, emphasized their pursuit of justice: “They need to be made whole.” The lawsuit seeks financial restitution for the lifelong pain and suffering endured by the family. Henley also voiced hopes that the lawsuit might prompt professional scrutiny of Dr. Patton, saying the family wants to ensure no other patient suffers similarly.
As of the latest reports, neither Methodist Dallas Medical Center nor Dr. Patton have issued a detailed response; the medical system has stated a policy of not commenting on ongoing litigation, and Dr. Patton has deferred to patient privacy laws. The Texas Medical Board records show no current public disciplinary actions against her.
The lawsuit, filed May 29 in Dallas County District Court, is still in its early stages. The Perkins family remains haunted by their profound loss, hoping the legal process will bring accountability and potentially help prevent future tragedies in childbirth.
